We flew back from the Yucatán into Atlanta on a Friday in early January and I headed home the next day. It was snowy and icy in the South and the drive was a little squirrelly until I go to the interstate. I don’t mind the cold but it was a shock after the beach, and I wanted a nice meal to ease the transition. So I decided to make sopa de lima, or lime soup. We had it for lunch on New Year’s Day in
Mérida at an outdoor café on a small downtown square. The soup had a generous helping of shredded chicken in an herbed and mildly spicy broth; it tasted of lime zest and had just a hint of acidity. It was served with fresh salsa and tortilla chips. Simple, but delicious and memorable. I got back to town a day before my girlfriend, so I set out to surprise her.
Sidewalk cafe in Mérida on a quiet New Year's Day
I chose a
Rick Bayless recipe as a start. He has a respectful approach informed by years of anthropological study, culinary training, and residence in Mexico. (You may have seen him on PBS or Top Chef Masters. He’s kind of a goober but it’s mostly endearing.) I have one of his later cookbooks but this recipe isn’t there, so I found it
on the internet. I followed it pretty closely, but here’s what I used:
For the stock:
1 3.5 lb organic chicken
2 medium white onions
2 heads of garlic
4-5 freshly ground peppercorns
~1/4 tsp cinnamon
~1/8 tsp clove
1 jalapeno and 2 banana peppers from the summer garden, thawed
small handful (2 tbs?) fresh oregano from the garden (I was lucky to have some that had survived or was flash-frozen on the stalk)
some pork (fatty boston butt trimmings from the freezer)
4 key limes (ends for stock; remainder sliced for later)
salt
For the soup:
meat from the chicken (see instructions)
1 green pepper, chopped
1 large white onion, chopped
3 medium tomatoes, chopped
For serving:
lime slices
fried corn tortillas
I usually keep a quart or two of home-made chicken stock in the freezer but I was out. Fortunately, for a chicken-based soup the lack of stock is an inconvenience but not a deal breaker. The recipe called for dry-toasting and caramelizing the aromatics, a technique I hadn’t used before, but I cut the two white onions and two full heads of garlic in half and laid them flesh-down in the pot on medium-low heat for 10-15 minutes. I added the pork for the last few minutes. I almost overdid it: the onions were a satisfying deep brown but the garlic surface was toasted just past the sweet nutty stage. Meanwhile, I coarsely ground the peppercorns and mixed them with the cinnamon and clove and broiled the peppers. I then added 3 or 4 quarts of water to the pot, brought it to a simmer, and added the chicken, a few teaspoons of salt, and the oregano, spices, and peppers. I cut the ends from 4 key limes and tossed those in as well (I reserved the lime centers for serving).

Sopa de lima and beans with greens
And here’s a trick, though not an especially clever one. If you need chicken meat and stock for a dish, poach the chicken and make it all at once. I kept the water at a scant boil and covered the pot for 45 minutes or an hour, skimming the foam and fat off regularly. When the leg and thigh wiggled freely, I pulled the chicken from the pot and put it on a plate. I let it cool for 20 minutes or so and then pulled the meat off and put it aside in a little bit of broth (if you let poached or braised meat cool completely out of liquid, it can dry out). I added the bones and skin back to the pot and returned it all to a simmer. When the stock was flavorful and the carcass broke apart (another hour or two), I poured it through two layers of cheesecloth in a mesh strainer and discarded the remnants. I put the stock aside to cool and skimmed the fat once in a while.
I wiped the pot clean, softened the chopped onion and green pepper in a bit of oil and then added the tomatoes. A few minutes later, I added the shredded chicken and the stock. When it was all warmed through it was ready to serve.
While the stock was finishing, I fried the tortillas. I like fried food as much as the next southerner, but I can count on one hand how often I’ve done it because frying is a big, messy pain in the ass. I put about ½” of vegetable oil in the skillet on medium heat and fried two tortillas, cut into strips, at a time. I did it all by look and feel and had moderate success. And since the mess was already made, I added a little more oil to the pan and fried some plantains to make
tostones.
Finally, I made a beans and greens dish inspired by a recipe in the Bayless cookbook I own,
Mexican Everyday. I cooked 2-3 tbs of meaty pork in the casserole until the fat rendered and added one whole diced jalapeno, seeds and all. When the pepper softened I added 2 cans of drained and rinsed black beans. I chopped two 10 oz. bags of spinach and wilted it in two batches in the skillet (wilting the spinach beforehand reduces the amount of liquid it gives off in the beans). When it was all combined I finished it with queso fresco.
Sopa de lima, beans and greens with queso fresco, tostonés, and a michelada
I’m glad to say that the timing was perfect. When she arrived and settled in I had tostonés hot and ready and served them with
cervezas preparadas (subjects of another post, maybe). I served the soup with the chips and thinly sliced limes. It was delicious, but it wasn’t quite like it had been in Mexico. I think the broth was too heavy – I’ve never mastered making a clear and defatted broth, though I’ve made hundreds. Mine always have good flavor but I don’t fuss enough to get the texture just right. Some of the chips were chewy in the center but they were good enough when tossed in the finished soup. With the beans and greens, it was a nice full meal and we happily had leftovers for days.